Skip to main content

Guy Rejected From Law Society

The end of law school is in sight- my exams start next week and by the end of April I will be a Western Law graduate! 

In order to obtain my licence to practice law in Ontario, the next step is for me to write the Bar exam in June and complete 10 months of articling- then I’ll be admitted to the Law Society of Upper Canada (LSUC) and will finally be a qualified lawyer.

But as Ryan Manilla has learned, meeting those two requirements doesn’t guarantee admission into the law society. Manilla is a graduate of Osgoode law school who was recently rejected from the Law Society for failure to meet its “good character” requirement.

According to the Toronto Star, Manilla was president of his condo board but got into a dispute with members over fee increases. He sent threatening emails to other members, and boasted that he got a thrill out of making other members squirm. He was kicked off the board; he forged a letter pretending to be a private investigator alleging kickbacks and other wrongdoings among board members. He was charged with four counts of criminal harassment, but the charges were dropped after he apologized to the board members, made charitable donations in their names and attended anger management classes.

Manilla appealed his rejection but the law society recently dismissed his appeal, partly on the grounds that not enough time has passed to show that he is of good character. (He admitted to forging the letter only five days before his hearing.)

While I sympathize a bit with Manilla, who has obviously worked hard to achieve his goal of being a lawyer – he graduated near the top of his class and summered and articled at prestigious law firms—I can also understand that the law society has a responsibility to maintain standards in the profession and to protect the public.

The Law Society Act doesn’t define good character, but it is something for those of us just entering the profession to keep in mind. In fact we should always keep it in mind, since the law society will be regulating us for the duration of our careers:  

“Character, in the long run, is the decisive factor in the life of an individual and of nations alike.”
-Theodore Roosevelt



  1. Comment from Sheena K:

    Sounds to me like the Law Society is acting like a proud parent rejecting her daughter's new boyfriend choice because he has a recent criminal record!

    Don't get me wrong, the Law Society has every right to reject applicants who do not meet the requirements of becoming a lawyer. It's their duty to ensure the credibility of the institution of law via their selection process. Thus, the criteria must include good character. However, they are directly equating good character with the lack of a recent criminal record and that's a dangerous precedent to be setting. How many other students are accepted to the LSUC with a few recent slaps on their wrists? Quite a few I would assume...

    I'm not arguing the importance of a bullet proof screening system, however, I'm not convinced recent criminal charges which have since been dropped and amends made quite warrants the title of an objective rejection.Therefore I would like to recommend a few additions to the screening process involving a deeper level of character: Personality Tests! I hear LavaLife and have a few good ones....


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Profile raising in South Florida: making the most of the Daily Business Review

Profile raising is an important aspect of your marketing and business development efforts. Demonstrating that you are a thought leader in your practice area - whether by writing articles or being quoted in news articles, can go a long way towards helping you stand out. There are many publications out there of course, but the focus of this post is the Daily Business Review (DBR) in South Florida.
Writing an article The DBR is an ALM publication reporting on the legal market in South Florida. An excellent opportunity for lawyers to write an article is through the DBR's Board of Contributors column. Articles should be about 800 words, and can be case-specific, about a specific area of the law, a trend, legislation affecting a particular field, or the business of law. If you have a topic to suggest, even better, as the DBR welcomes new content. You'll also need to include a 1-sentence bio and a high resolution headshot, and will be required to sign the DBR's standard rights ag…

Book Review: Accelerating Lawyer Success

What does success look like in law firms? The authors, frustrated with the abundance of anecdotal evidence and lack of empirical evidence to answer this question, set out to solve it with research. Their findings are based on studies including a comprehensive, 75-item survey completed by 343 lawyers at U.S. AmLaw 100 firms. They examine, among other things, the differences between lawyers who made partner in less than 10 years and those who didn't.
Accelerating Lawyer Success: How to Make Partner, Stay Healthy, and Flourish in a Law Firm. By Lori Berman, Heather Bock, and Juliet Aiken. 

The authors have uncovered the recipe for how to make partner in less than 10 years. In short, it involves hard work and quality work, strategic relationship building, planning, help from mentors, and a mind-set of being the master of your own fate. You gotta build relationships strategically, invest in them, and leverage them. You need goals, to make plans, and to stick to them for the most part. An…

The Science of Happiness Explained

I'm at the Legal Marketing Association (LMA) 2018 Annual Conference in New Orleans, and almost skipped the keynote session - because an hour-long talk about happiness sounded irritating. But actually I didn't want to strangle the speaker at all. 

The Happiness Professor as she is known, is Catherine Sanderson. She teaches at Amherst College and has degrees from Princeton and Stanford. She presented research from the field of positive psychology that looks at the factors that do (and do not) predict happiness, and provided practical ways that we can increase our own psychological well-being.
Things we think will make us happy, but really don’t: Money. (Note: for people worried about survival, this doesn’t apply.) But beyond that, the more of it one has, the more one wants. 
Climate. Not convinced about this one. As a person who has been living in Florida for 6 years, from Canada, I can tell you that she may have gotten this one wrong. 
Life event. In other words, when X thing happ…